Why “Storm Chasers” Hurt Homeowners and the Insurance Industry — And What Ethical Contractors Do Differently
- Scott White
- Jan 11
- 4 min read
When severe weather strikes, homeowners are often left stressed, uncertain, and vulnerable. In those moments, one group of contractors tends to appear almost immediately — storm-chasing roofing companies — promising fast insurance payouts, “free roofs,” or expedited repairs.
While these offers may sound appealing, the storm-chasing business model frequently creates long-term harm for homeowners and systemic challenges for insurance agents, adjusters, and carriers.
At Winchester Roofing, we believe roofing contractors should support — not undermine — the integrity of the insurance process. Below, we outline how storm chasers negatively impact homeowners and the insurance industry, and why ethical, local contractors play a critical role in protecting both.
What Are Storm Chasers?
Storm chasers are typically out-of-area roofing contractors who follow severe weather events — such as hail or windstorms — into affected neighborhoods. Their approach is often characterized by door-to-door sales, pressure tactics, and promises to “handle the insurance claim” on behalf of the homeowner.
Because these companies rely on short-term volume rather than long-term accountability, their incentives are often misaligned with proper damage assessment, repair accuracy, and workmanship quality.
The Impact on Homeowners
For homeowners, the consequences of working with storm-chasing contractors can be significant:
Unnecessary or premature claims may be filed for damage that could otherwise be addressed through targeted repairs, contributing to avoidable claim history and potential premium impacts.
Inflated scopes of work may result in full roof replacements when localized repairs are appropriate, exposing homeowners to future underwriting or insurability challenges.
Substandard installation quality can lead to leaks, premature failure, and warranty issues once the contractor has left the area.
Limited recourse becomes a serious issue when storm chasers disappear after the work is completed.
Insurance fraud — including contractor-driven property fraud — costs insurers and consumers over $40 billion annually, according to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, with roofing-related fraud representing a significant contributor to those losses.¹ These costs ultimately affect homeowners through higher premiums and reduced carrier appetite in high-loss regions.
The Cost to the Insurance Industry
Storm chasers don’t just impact individual homeowners — they strain the entire insurance ecosystem.
Catastrophic weather events now account for more than 40% of U.S. homeowners insurance losses, with both claim frequency and severity increasing substantially since 2019.² As claim volumes rise, carriers and adjusters are under increasing pressure to manage inflated scopes, questionable documentation, and disputes driven by contractor behavior rather than actual damage.
The National Insurance Crime Bureau has documented a rise in questionable and inflated roofing claims, particularly following hail and wind events, noting that these trends contribute to rising loss costs and heightened scrutiny across the industry.³
In response, many state departments of insurance have issued consumer warnings regarding storm-chasing contractors, citing concerns including high-pressure sales tactics, lack of licensing or insurance, inadequate warranties, and increased long-term repair risks for homeowners.⁴
These trends not only drive higher premiums but also complicate claims handling, increase litigation risk, and erode trust between homeowners, carriers, and contractors.
Why Ethical, Local Roofing Contractors Matter
At Winchester Roofing, we believe roofing contractors should act as responsible trade partners — not claim accelerators.
Our approach is built on principles that align closely with the goals of insurance professionals:
Honest Assessments
We perform thorough evaluations and recommend repair versus replacement based on actual damage, building codes, and manufacturer requirements — not on maximizing claim totals.
Proper Installation & Warranty Protection
We install roofing systems correctly the first time, offering:
Lifetime manufacturer warranties on qualifying asphalt shingle systems
Workmanship warranties on labor and installation for full roof replacements
Proper installation helps ensure warranty eligibility and reduces the likelihood of repeat claims or future losses.
Documentation & Communication
We provide clear documentation, accurate scopes, and professional communication to support clean, defensible claims files and smooth resolution for all parties involved.
Local Accountability
With a permanent office and showroom in downtown Winchester, we are a long-term presence in the community — accountable to homeowners, agents, and carriers long after the storm has passed.
A Better Path Forward
Severe weather is increasing, and catastrophic claims now represent a substantial portion of insurer losses nationwide.⁵ In this environment, ethical contractor relationships are more important than ever.
Insurance agents and adjusters benefit from working with contractors who:
Respect coverage determinations
Avoid unnecessary claim escalation
Install durable, code-compliant roofing systems
Stand behind their work long after claim closure
Storm chasers may promise speed and simplicity — but ethical, local contractors deliver stability, integrity, and long-term protection for homeowners and the insurance industry alike.
If you are an insurance professional looking for a trusted local roofing partner who understands your responsibilities and shares your values, we welcome the opportunity to connect.
Footnotes & Sources
¹ Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) – Insurance Fraud Overview The FBI estimates insurance fraud (excluding health insurance) costs insurers and consumers over $40 billion annually, with property and contractor-related fraud representing a significant portion of those losses.
² LexisNexis® Risk Solutions – Catastrophic Property Claims Analysis LexisNexis reports catastrophic weather events now account for over 40% of homeowners insurance losses, with rising claim severity and frequency since 2019.
³ National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) – Roofing & Property Fraud Reports NICB documents increasing trends in inflated and questionable roofing claims, particularly following hail and wind events.
⁴ State Departments of Insurance (Multiple States) – Consumer Protection Bulletins State DOIs routinely warn consumers about storm-chasing contractors, citing high-pressure sales tactics, lack of accountability, inadequate warranties, and increased long-term risk.
⁵ Insurance Information Institute (III) – Homeowners Insurance & Catastrophe Data The III reports continued increases in severe weather-related claims and rising repair costs impacting underwriting and premium stability.
Winchester Roofing
Winchester Roofing is a trusted, locally owned roofing company in Winchester, VA, specializing in high-quality roof replacement, roof repair, siding, windows, gutters, and storm damage restoration services. As one of the leading roofing contractors in Virginia, we proudly serve homeowners and businesses with expert solutions that protect and enhance your property.
Statistics reflect national industry trends. Individual claim outcomes depend on policy terms, damage conditions, and local code and manufacturer requirements.
Comments